PERM Proposed Rule Released – Analysis and Overview of the Proposed Changes
The Department of Labor (DOL) released earlier today a highly anticipated proposed rule seeking to fundamentally change the PERM labor certification program. The proposed rule seeks to implement significant changes that will expand employers’ recruitment obligations, heighten DOL scrutiny of all PERM applications, and strengthen protections for the U.S. workforce.
It is important to note that this is a proposed rule which is subject to a 60-day public comment period and is subject to potential changes and delays. The revisions will not take effect until the regulation clears the federal rulemaking process and is published as a final rule.
According to DOL, the current PERM process (basically unchanged for 20+ years) relies on outdated print recruitment methods and lacks sufficient upfront documentation to effectively verify that there are no qualified, available U.S. workers. We focus our analysis below on the new and changed provisions that will most directly impact employers.
Executive Summary of the Proposed Rule
-
Modernized and Standardized Recruitment. The rule eliminates the print advertisement requirements and required a standard set of digital recruitment steps for nearly all PERM positions, requiring a minimum active recruitment period of 90 days (increase from 30 days).
-
Stricter Layoff Prohibitions. Employers will be prohibited from filing a PERM application if they have laid off U.S. workers in the same or similar occupation within the two years prior to filing (increase from 6 months).
-
Elimination of Schedule A. The rule seeks to eliminate Schedule A entirely, meaning occupations previously exempt from the labor market test (such as professional nurses, physical therapists, and individuals of exceptional ability) will now require full PERM recruitment.
-
Upfront Documentation Requirements. Employers will be required to submit all recruitment materials, the recruitment report, and the Notice of Filing concurrently with the PERM application at the time of filing. Under the current PERM rule, these documents had to be provided to DOL only upon audit/request.
-
Expanded Notice of Filing (NOF). The NOF must be posted at least 10 business days before filing and must remain available continuously through the date the subsequent Form I-140 petition is approved by USCIS.
Below are more details and analysis of the significant new provisions of the proposed rule:
Revisions to PERM Recruitment Requirements
The proposed rule represents a major overhaul of current recruitment requirements, significantly expanding the minimum duration of recruitment and mandating that PERM recruitment mirror or exceed the employer’s normal methods for non-PERM openings.
Standardized Recruitment Steps. The rule eliminates the distinction between professional and non-professional positions, as well as the menu of optional recruitment steps. Instead, employers must complete a mandatory set of recruitment activities:
-
Placement of a job order with the State Workforce Agency (SWA).
-
Placement of an advertisement on the employer’s website(s) in the location customarily used for non-PERM recruitment.
-
Placement of an advertisement on at least one third-party job search website.
-
Advertisement on social media platforms, if customarily used by the employer for similar non-PERM roles.
-
Advertisement through at least one job fair, on-campus recruiting event, or college/trade school placement office.
Duration and Timeline of Recruitment. PERM recruitment will now be required to run for a minimum of 90 calendar days, or for the length of time the employer customarily advertises for non-PERM opportunities if that timeframe is longer. Also, all recruitment must be completed no more than 60 days and no fewer than 30 days before the expected PERM filing date. This strict 30-day post-recruitment window is designed to ensure the labor market test is not stale at the time of filing and to provide adequate time for the employer to draft the required recruitment report.
Stricter Layoff Rules and Considerations
Under the current rules, an employer with a layoff in the area of intended employment within six months of filing must merely document that it notified potentially qualified laid-off U.S. workers.
Two-Year Layoff Prohibition. The proposed rule categorically prohibits the filing of a PERM application if the employer has had a layoff involving the same or a similar occupation in the area of intended employment within the two years prior to the PERM application.
Post-Filing Layoff Obligations. The rule also creates unprecedented ongoing reporting requirements for layoffs that occur after the PERM application is filed. Employers must affirmatively notify the DOL (and USCIS, if the I-140 is pending) within five business days of a post-filing layoff. The employer must also formally offer the PERM job opportunity to potentially qualified laid-off U.S. workers, document the results, and update their recruitment report.
Expanded Notice of Filing (NOF) and Upfront Documentation
Notice of Filing Timeline and Placement. In a major change from current regulations, the NOF must be posted within the 10 business days prior to the PERM filing and must continue to be displayed continuously through the date the I-140 immigrant petition is approved by USCIS (or until the application/petition is denied or withdrawn). The DOL will permit electronic posting on an internal/external employer website in lieu of physical posting if the site is readily accessible to all employees. The NOF requirement is also extended to third-party worksites if the sponsored worker will be placed at a client location.
Upfront Submission of Evidence. Currently, PERM operates as an attestation-based system where supporting documentation is only submitted if the application is selected for an audit. Under the proposal, employers must submit a comprehensive evidentiary package at the time of filing via the FLAG system, including:
-
The tracking number tying the application to a valid Prevailing Wage Determination (PWD).
-
Notice of Filing compliance documentation.
-
A detailed recruitment report.
-
Proof of all recruitment activities (e.g., website printouts, job order confirmations).
-
Resumes and applications for all U.S. workers who applied for the PERM position.
Elimination of Schedule A
Under existing regulations, permanent residence cases involving occupations identified in Schedule A (professional nurses, physical therapists, and individuals of exceptional ability in the arts or sciences) are exempt from the labor market test, significantly accelerating their green card timeline. The proposed rule seeks to eliminate Schedule A entirely, requiring these previously exempt occupations to undergo the full PERM recruitment and application process.
Comparison of Current vs. Proposed PERM Rule Provisions
| Feature/Requirement | Current PERM Rule | New Proposed PERM Rule |
| Occupational Distinctions |
Differentiates recruitment steps for professional vs. non-professional occupations.
|
Standardizes recruitment steps for almost all occupations, eliminating the distinction between professional and non-professional roles.
|
| Schedule A Exemptions |
Schedule A exempts certain occupations (professional nurses, physical therapists, aliens of exceptional ability) from the labor market test entirely.
|
Schedule A is eliminated. All previously exempt occupations must undergo the full labor market test.
|
| Required Recruitment Steps |
Non-Professional: SWA Job Order (30 days) + 2 Sunday print newspaper ads.
Professional: SWA Job Order (30 days) + 2 Sunday print newspaper ads + 3 additional steps chosen from a menu of 10 options.
|
All Occupations: Print ads and the menu of options are eliminated. Employers must use standard digital/modern methods:
• SWA Job Order.
• Advertisement on the employer’s website(s).
• Advertisement on at least one third-party job search website.
• Advertisement on social media platforms (if customarily used by the employer).
• Job fair, on-campus recruiting, or college/trade school placement office.
|
| Mirroring Standard Practices |
The recruitment methods do not strictly have to mirror how the employer recruits for non-PERM openings.
|
Recruitment methods must mirror or exceed the employer’s customary methods for non-PERM job opportunities in the same occupational classification.
|
| Duration of Active Recruitment |
The SWA Job Order must run for 30 days. Other advertisements (like print ads) run on specific dates without a minimum continuous duration requirement for the whole campaign.
|
Active recruitment across mandatory channels must run for a minimum of 90 calendar days, or for the length of time the employer customarily advertises for similar non-PERM roles, whichever is longer.
|
| Recruitment Timeline (Pre-Filing) |
Recruitment activities must be conducted between 30 and 180 days before filing the PERM application.
|
Recruitment must be completed no more than 60 days and no fewer than 30 days prior to filing the application.
|
| Notice of Filing (NOF) Posting |
Must be posted internally for 10 consecutive business days during the 30- to 180-day period prior to filing.
|
Must begin posting within 10 business days before filing and remain continuously displayed through the date the I-140 petition is approved by USCIS (or until the application is denied/withdrawn).
|
| NOF Location/Format |
Must be physically posted at the worksite.
|
Permits electronic posting (e.g., company intranet) if readily accessible and customarily used for notices. Extends posting requirement to third-party worksites.
|
| Submission of Evidence |
Attestation-based system: Employers retain recruitment evidence and the recruitment report in a compliance file and only submit it if audited by the DOL.
|
Front-loaded evidentiary system: Employers must submit the recruitment report, NOF documentation, proof of advertisements, and all applicant resumes concurrently with the PERM application at the time of filing.
|
| Applicant Interviews |
No specific requirement regarding who conducts the interview or the format (though they must be conducted fairly).
|
Interviews must be conducted virtually or by phone to minimize costs for U.S. workers. The interviewer must be a U.S. worker who normally interviews candidates for comparable non-PERM roles.
|
Anticipated Significant Negative Impact on Employers
The proposed PERM rule will significantly increase the administrative burden and timelines for employers sponsoring foreign talent. Shifting to a front-loaded evidentiary model, companies must now submit comprehensive recruitment proofs, detailed reports, and applicant resumes at the exact time of filing. The pre-filing phase will extend to at least 9 to 10 months due to 5-month Prevailing Wage Determinations, mandatory 90-day active recruitment campaigns, and a strict 30- to 60-day post-recruitment waiting period.
Additionally, a strict two-year lookback prohibition on layoffs in related occupations will temporarily bar many companies from utilizing the PERM program, while new post-filing rules will require ongoing monitoring and reporting of subsequent layoffs. Finally, employers in healthcare and specialized industries will lose the expedited processing benefits of Schedule A, forcing them to conduct full labor market tests for historically exempt occupations such as professional nurses and physical therapists.
Proposed Implementation Timeframe
The DOL is accepting public feedback on the proposed regulation for a 60-day comment period. Once the comment period closes, the DOL will review the feedback and draft the final rule.
If finalized as proposed, there will be a 90-day transition period following the publication of the final rule (a 60-day delayed effective date plus an additional 30 days for transition). The new regulations will apply to any PERM applications and Prevailing Wage Determinations submitted on or after the conclusion of that 90-day transition period.
Conclusion
One of our office’s core areas of expertise are employment immigration and PERM Labor Certifications and we will continue to monitor the progress of this proposed rule closely and we will provide updates. Please do not hesitate to contact us if we can help you. Please visit us again or subscribe to our free weekly newsletter to ensure that you obtain this and related immigration-related news and announcements.
Related News and Articles
The Capitol Immigration Law Group has been serving the business community for over 15 years and is one of the most widely respected immigration law firms focused solely on U.S. employment-based immigration. Disclaimer: we make all efforts to provide timely and accurate information; however, the information in this article may become outdated or may not be applicable to a specific set of facts. It is not to be construed as legal advice.
